Appellate jurisdiction under Central Excise turns on whether an Additional Collector's order lies to the Tribunal or Collector (Appeals).

Under the Central Excise appeal scheme, an order passed by an Additional Collector of Central Excise was treated as one made by an authority administratively subordinate to the Collector, not as an order of a Collector for appellate purposes. The statutory framework distinguished the powers of a Collector from those of an Assistant Collector, including notification-based conferral of powers, and that distinction meant the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to hear an appeal or stay application against the Additional Collector's order under the provision governing appeals from Collector adjudications. The proper appellate forum was the Collector (Appeals), Delhi.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain the appeal and stay application against the order passed by the Additional Collector of Central Excise, and whether the proper appellate forum was the Tribunal or the Collector (Appeals).

Analysis: The order examined the statutory scheme governing adjudication and appeals under the Central Excise Rules and the Central Excise Act. It distinguished the position of an Additional Collector under the excise regime from the wider position of an Additional Collector under the customs law. The relevant provisions showed that while a Collector could exercise unlimited adjudicatory powers, an Assistant Collector's powers were limited and the Board could confer powers by notification. The reasoning treated the Additional Collector of Central Excise as administratively subordinate to the Collector and not as a Collector for the purpose of adjudication under the appeal provisions. On that basis, an appeal from such an order did not lie to the Tribunal under the provision governing appeals from orders of a Collector as adjudicating authority.

Conclusion: The Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain the appeal, and the proper appellate forum was the Collector (Appeals), Delhi.

---