Goods classification turns on essential character: surgical gloves fall under the specific equipment entry, while examination gloves remain rubber products.

For sales tax classification under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, the essential character, function and commercial description of the goods govern whether they fall within the specific surgical-equipment entry or the general rubber-products entry. Sterilised and non-sterilised surgical gloves, being used and marketed as surgical appliances, were treated as surgical equipment under entry 145, with the material used not altering that character. Examination gloves, however, were used for patient examination, were not marketed as surgical gloves, and remained classifiable as rubber products under entry 125. The note reflects that a specific entry prevails over a general entry when the goods answer the specific description.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether sterilized and non-sterilized surgical gloves are taxable as surgical equipment under entry 145 of the First Schedule to the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 or as rubber products under entry 125; (ii) Whether examination gloves are taxable as surgical equipment under entry 145 or as rubber products under entry 125.

Issue (i): Whether sterilized and non-sterilized surgical gloves are taxable as surgical equipment under entry 145 of the First Schedule to the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 or as rubber products under entry 125.

Analysis: Entry 145 covers surgical equipment and instruments, and the expression is to be understood by reference to the use and purpose of the goods. Gloves used by surgeons and others engaged in surgery are essential equipment for surgical work. The material of which the gloves are made does not alter their essential character when they are marketed and used as surgical gloves. Where a product answers a specific entry, it is not to be forced into the general rubber-products entry.

Conclusion: Sterilized surgical gloves and non-sterilized surgical gloves are taxable under entry 145 at 8 per cent, and not under entry 125.

Issue (ii): Whether examination gloves are taxable as surgical equipment under entry 145 or as rubber products under entry 125.

Analysis: Examination gloves are used for examination of patients and are of a different quality from surgical gloves. They are not earmarked or marketed as surgical gloves and do not answer the description of surgical equipment. As they are rubber products and do not fall under the specific surgical-equipment entry, they remain within the general rubber-products entry.

Conclusion: Examination gloves are taxable under entry 125 at 12 per cent.

Final Conclusion: The revision succeeded only in part, with surgical gloves classified under the lower-rate surgical-equipment entry and examination gloves retained under the rubber-products entry.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax classification, a goods entry must be determined by the goods' essential character, function, and commercial description; a specific entry for surgical equipment prevails over a general entry for rubber products when the article is marketed and used as a surgical appliance.

---