2009 (10) TMI 858 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Court rules in favor of petitioner in sales tax dispute on incorrect tax rate, nullifies penalty order

Rajesh Electricals Versus Registrar, MP. Commercial Tax, Appeal Board, Bhopal and others

The High Court ruled in favor of the petitioner in a sales tax dispute concerning the declaration of a lower tax rate on electrical goods. The Court found ... - Issues:1. Discrepancy in sales tax rate declared by the petitioner on electrical goods.2. Imposition of penalty by the assessing officer.3. Dismissal of application under section 71 of the M.P. Commercial Tax Act, 1994 by the Board.Analysis:The petitioner, engaged in the sale of electrical goods, declared a lower tax rate on starters and switches in their sales tax return, depositing tax at 3% instead of 12%. The assessing officer deemed the return false, imposed a penalty, and ordered tax recovery at 12%. The matter reached the Commercial Tax Appellate Board, which sided with the petitioner, affirming the 3% tax rate. Subsequently, the petitioner sought a decision on the penalty issue under section 71, but the Board dismissed the application citing non-raised grounds. The petitioner argued that if the tax rate was 3%, the penalty for a supposedly false return would be baseless. Conversely, the State contended that section 71 application approval requires valid grounds.Upon review, the High Court noted the assessing officer's error in determining the tax rate and imposing the penalty based on the incorrect rate. Given the Board's findings supporting the 3% tax rate, the Court concluded that the petitioner's return was valid and tax paid correctly. Consequently, the assessing officer lacked jurisdiction to levy the penalty. In light of the Board's decision, the Court nullified the penalty order, ruling in favor of the petitioner and allowing the petition without costs.