Internal government dispute resolution through committee review can delay tax recovery until the committee decides

Inter-departmental tax disputes involving a Government undertaking and the Trade Tax Department should ordinarily be resolved through the prescribed Secretary Level Committee mechanism before court proceedings are pursued. The court applied the principle that disputes between limbs of the Government or its instrumentalities should first be settled internally to avoid avoidable litigation. On that basis, the matter was directed to be taken up by the Committee, and coercive recovery was stayed until the Committee reached a final decision.

---

---

Issues: Whether a tax dispute between a Government undertaking and the Trade Tax Department should be routed through the Secretary Level Committee before being pursued in court, and whether recovery proceedings should remain stayed pending the Committee's decision.

Analysis: The dispute was treated as one between limbs of the same Government. The governing principle applied was that inter-departmental controversies and disputes involving public sector entities should ordinarily be resolved at the Government level through the prescribed committee mechanism rather than by court litigation. The judgment also noted that courts should insist upon such clearance where the dispute has not been settled internally, and that frivolous or avoidable litigation should not be brought before the court. In light of the applicable Government Order, the matter was directed to be sorted out by the Secretary Level Committee, and recovery was ordered to remain stayed until the Committee took a final decision.

Conclusion: The revisions were not decided on merits and were directed to be taken up through the Secretary Level Committee, with recovery stayed in the meantime.

Final Conclusion: The dispute was disposed of by requiring internal governmental resolution first, and the coercive recovery process was suspended until that mechanism concluded its consideration.

Ratio Decidendi: Inter-departmental disputes involving the Government or its instrumentalities should be resolved through the prescribed committee mechanism before resorting to court proceedings, and courts may stay recovery pending such resolution.

---