Commercial meaning controls tax classification: battery-assisted e-bikes fall outside "bicycle" and into the residuary entry.

Sales tax classification turns on the ordinary commercial meaning of the entry, read in context. An electrically assisted battery-operated bicycle with an auxiliary motor was held not to be a "bicycle" under Schedule C, entry 14 of the Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act, because the statutory setting suggested a narrower class of manually propelled conveyances such as tricycles and cycle rickshaws. The product's battery power, motor assistance, and market presentation as an e-bike showed a material distinction from a conventional pedal-driven bicycle, so it was correctly classified under the residuary entry.

---

---

Issues: Whether an electrically assisted battery-operated bicycle with pedal assistance was classifiable as "bicycle" under Schedule C, entry 14 of the Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act, 2002, or was liable to tax under the residuary entry.

Analysis: The expression "bicycle" in a taxing entry was required to be understood in its common parlance and commercial sense. The decisive features of the product were that it ran with the assistance of electric battery power, had an auxiliary motor, and was marketed as an e-bike rather than a conventional pedal-driven bicycle. The Court also applied the contextual rule of construction, noting that the word "bicycle" occurred alongside related items such as "tricycles" and "cycle rickshaws", which supported a narrower genus of manually propelled conveyances. The brochure and specifications showed that the product was materially different from an ordinary bicycle, and the classification suggested by the assessee would create an unintended tax anomaly by indirectly lowering the tax on the battery component.

Conclusion: The product did not fall within Schedule C, entry 14 as a "bicycle" and was rightly assessed under the residuary entry. The appeal was therefore not maintainable on merits.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax classification, a commodity must be identified according to its ordinary commercial understanding, and a battery-powered electrically assisted vehicle is not a "bicycle" where the statutory entry, read in context, contemplates a pedal-driven conveyance.

---