Entry tax applies only where goods enter a local area for consumption, use, or sale there, not for weighment alone.

Entry tax on goods entering a local area is attracted only when the entry is for consumption, use, or sale within that area. Coal brought in merely for weighment at a weighbridge and then dispatched did not satisfy that condition, and the levy could not be sustained on the basis that sale was completed for price ascertainment under the Sale of Goods Act. The operative test remained the intended local consumption, use, or sale of the goods. On that reasoning, coal entered only for weighment and onward movement outside the area was not liable to entry tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether coal brought into local areas only for weighment at weighbridges and thereafter dispatched outside those areas was liable to entry tax under the Entry Tax Act.

Analysis: Liability under the charging provision arose only when entry of goods into the local area was for consumption, use or sale therein. The expression "sale therein" was construed consistently with the settled interpretation of entry tax and octroi as meaning a sale of goods within the local area for consumption or use therein. Goods brought into the local area merely for weighment, without being intended for consumption, use, or sale within that area, did not attract the levy. The completion of sale for purposes of price ascertainment under the Sale of Goods Act did not control the chargeability under the entry tax regime.

Conclusion: The assessee was not liable to entry tax on coal brought into the local area only for weighment and then taken out for use or consumption elsewhere.

Ratio Decidendi: Entry tax under a levy framed on the entry of goods into a local area for consumption, use or sale therein is attracted only when the goods are intended for consumption, use, or sale within that local area; mere entry for weighment or other incidental purposes does not create liability.

---