Commercial parlance test governs classification of non-stick aluminium cookware under the broader home appliances entry.

Non-stick cookware made of aluminium is classified by its ordinary and commercial identity, not merely by its base material. Aluminium household utensils under entry 5 cover ordinary domestic utensils made of aluminium or aluminium alloys in their primary form, whereas coated non-stick cookware, finished with satilon to add non-stick qualities and enhanced utility, is not treated in trade as an aluminium household utensil. Entry 104, which covers similar home appliances not falling elsewhere, was treated as the appropriate classification because it specifically accommodates this distinct value-added category of goods. The earlier view placing coated aluminium non-stick items under entry 5 was disapproved.

---

---

Issues: Whether non-stick cookware made of aluminium is classifiable under entry 5 of the First Schedule to the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963 as aluminium household utensils, or under entry 104 of the First Schedule as similar home appliances not falling under any other entry.

Analysis: Entry 5 was held to cover only household utensils made of aluminium or aluminium alloys in their primary form, understood in common and commercial parlance as ordinary domestic kitchen utensils. Non-stick cookware, though made of aluminium, is coated inside and outside with satilon to impart non-stick qualities and enhanced utility, and in trade it is not regarded as an aluminium household utensil. Entry 104, which expressly includes pressure cookers, cook-and-serve ware, casseroles, water filters and similar home appliances not covered elsewhere, was treated as the appropriate entry because non-stick cookware is a distinct class of value-added home appliance. The earlier view treating coated aluminium non-stick items as falling under entry 5 was disapproved.

Conclusion: Non-stick cookware made of aluminium is classifiable under entry 104 of the First Schedule to the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, and not under entry 5.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax classification, a commodity must be classified according to its ordinary and commercial parlance identity, and where a specific entry covers a distinct value-added class of goods, that entry prevails over a broader entry for ordinary articles.

---