Hire charges for company-owned cylinders taxed as use of goods, while lost-cylinder turnover remained taxable at the relevant rate.

Cylinder holding charges for company-owned cylinders were treated as hire consideration for the use of goods, because the contract required return of the cylinders after use and the charge depended on the period of retention; they were therefore not part of the sale price of gas and were assessable under the transfer-of-right-to-use provision rather than the general sales provision. Amounts recovered for lost cylinders were also held taxable, being linked to the replacement value of the cylinders, and the applicable rate was taken as 5%, with the remand for recalculation of the correct turnover sustained. The result was that the taxability of both turnovers remained, subject to the corrected statutory basis and fresh quantification.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether cylinder holding charges collected for company-owned cylinders were taxable under section 3(2) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 or under section 3-A of that Act. (ii) Whether the turnover relating to lost cylinders was taxable and at what rate.

Issue (i): Whether cylinder holding charges collected for company-owned cylinders were taxable under section 3(2) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 or under section 3-A of that Act.

Analysis: The contract terms showed that the cylinders were supplied only to hold the gas and were to be returned after use. The charges were computed with reference to the period for which the cylinders remained with the customer, which showed that the amount was for use of the cylinders and not part of the sale price of gas. The transaction was therefore not an indivisible sale of gas and cylinders together. The charge answered the character of hire charges and fell within the statutory scheme governing transfer of the right to use goods.

Conclusion: Cylinder holding charges are taxable, but not under section 3(2); they are assessable under section 3-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.

Issue (ii): Whether the turnover relating to lost cylinders was taxable and at what rate.

Analysis: The amount recovered towards lost cylinders represented the replacement value of the cylinders. The matter had already been treated as taxable in principle, and the remaining question was only the proper rate and correct turnover to be worked out from the books. The remand for recalculation was justified, and the applicable rate was the rate relevant to cylinders.

Conclusion: The turnover relating to lost cylinders is taxable at 5% and the remand for determination of correct turnover was upheld.

Final Conclusion: The revision petitions succeeded only to the extent of correcting the statutory basis for cylinder holding charges, but the taxability of the disputed turnovers was maintained and the remand directions for fresh quantification were sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a charge is levied for retaining company-owned cylinders solely for the use of gas contained in them and the amount is measured by the duration of such retention, the charge is hire consideration for use of goods rather than part of the sale price of the gas.

---