Machinery parts classification prevails where leather and rubber belts are used in textile machinery, not general goods entries.

Leather belting and rubber belting used in textile machinery were treated as machinery parts rather than as leather goods or rubber goods under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The Tribunal held that item 81, which covers machinery, parts, accessories and tools used with machinery, was the specific entry applicable because the belts were used in textile factories as machinery parts. Items 116 and 126 were narrower or more general descriptive entries for leather goods and rubber products and did not apply on these facts. The classification under item 81 was therefore affirmed, and the Revenue's revision failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether leather belting and rubber belting used in textile machinery are classifiable as machinery parts under item 81 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, or as leather goods under item 116 and rubber goods under item 126.

Analysis: Item 81 covers machinery as well as parts, accessories and tools used with such machinery. The materials on record showed that both leather belting and rubber belting were used as machinery parts in textile factories. Item 116 applies to goods made wholly or principally of leather other than footwear, while item 126 covers rubber products, including transmission, conveyor or elevator belts or beltings. On the facts, the belts in question were used as machinery parts and did not fall within the residual leather or rubber goods entries. The Tribunal's classification under item 81 was therefore correct.

Conclusion: The belts were taxable under item 81 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and not under items 116 or 126.

Final Conclusion: The revision filed by the Revenue failed, and the assessee's classification was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods are used as parts of machinery and a specific schedule entry covers machinery, parts and accessories, that specific entry prevails over broader descriptive entries for leather or rubber goods.

---