Trade meaning controls sales tax classification where an entry uses an unqualified description, not the product's end-use.

An unqualified commercial description in a sales tax entry is to be applied according to the trade meaning of the goods, not their ultimate end-use. The Tribunal held that the expression "lacquer" in entry 51 of Part A of Schedule IV was wide enough to cover all goods answering that description, and that ejusdem generis could not narrow its plain scope. On the material, including the applicant's literature, transport documents and trade certificate, Corial Lacquer FM was known in trade parlance as lacquer, even though used in the leather industry as a finishing material. It was therefore correctly classified as lacquer, and the seizures for non-production of the sales tax permit were valid.

---

---

Issues: Whether Corial Lacquer FM fell within entry 51 of Part A of Schedule IV of the West Bengal Sales Tax Act, 1994, and whether the seizures made for non-production of sales tax permit were valid.

Analysis: The expression "lacquer" in entry 51 was held to be unqualified and wide enough to include all goods answering that description, irrespective of their ultimate use. The principle of ejusdem generis was held inapplicable because of the wording of the entry. The material before the Tribunal, including the applicant's own literature, the transport documents, and the trade certificate, showed that the goods were known in trade parlance as lacquer, even though they were used in the leather industry as a chemical or finishing material. Since the statute did not restrict lacquer by reference to paint-related end-use, the commercial identity of the goods controlled their classification.

Conclusion: Corial Lacquer FM was correctly treated as lacquer under entry 51, and the seizures were valid.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tariff or sales tax entry uses an unqualified commercial description, classification depends on the trade meaning of the goods and not on their end-use, and ejusdem generis cannot be invoked to cut down that plain description.

---