Sales tax classification of voltage stabilizers turns on specific mention versus broad accessory language in the schedule.

Voltage stabilizers sold with refrigerators and television sets were discussed for Tamil Nadu sales tax classification, with the key issue being whether they were covered as "accessories" under entries 4 and 5 or fell within entry 41-A for electrical instruments, apparatus and appliances not otherwise specifically mentioned. The analysis treats "accessories" as a broad expression that can include a stabilizer as an aid or addition to the principal goods, but it also stresses that exclusion from the general electrical entry requires specific and express identification elsewhere in the Schedule. On that reading, a general reference to accessories did not specifically mention voltage stabilizers, so they were treated as falling under entry 41-A.

---

---

Issues: Whether voltage stabilizers sold by the assessee were classifiable under entry 41-A of Schedule I to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, or under entries 4 or 5 of the same Schedule as accessories of refrigerators or television sets.

Analysis: The expression "accessories" in entries 4 and 5 was wide enough to cover voltage stabilizers as an aid or addition to the specified goods. However, entry 41-A applied only to electrical instruments, apparatus and appliances other than those specifically mentioned elsewhere in the Schedule. The controlling question was whether a general reference to "accessories thereof" in entries 4 and 5 amounted to specific mention of voltage stabilizers. Reading the words "specified" and "specifically mentioned" in their ordinary sense, and applying the principle that a specific classification must be expressed with sufficient precision, the general expression in entries 4 and 5 did not specifically identify voltage stabilizers.

Conclusion: Voltage stabilizers were not specifically mentioned in entries 4 or 5 and therefore fell under entry 41-A alone.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded in its challenge to the Tribunal's classification, and the turnover relating to voltage stabilizers was held taxable under the residuary electrical entry rather than the accessory entries.

Ratio Decidendi: A commodity is excluded from a general entry only when it is specifically and expressly identified elsewhere in the Schedule; a broad reference to "accessories" does not amount to specific mention for classification purposes.

---