Single-point sales tax scheme allowed deduction of tendu leaf sale price where tax had already been paid at first stage.

Section 2(r)(ii) of the M.P. General Sales Tax Act was construed in the context of single-point taxation for tendu leaves. The Court held that the requirement that goods be purchased from a registered dealer was not confined to the assessee's immediate seller where the goods had already suffered tax at the first stage through a registered dealer. Read consistently with the single-point scheme, the provision allowed deduction of the sale price from taxable turnover in such circumstances. The earlier narrower view was not followed after later Supreme Court interpretation of a similar scheme, and the deduction was therefore available to the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for the purpose of section 2(r)(ii) of the M.P. General Sales Tax Act, 1958, the sale price of tendu leaves could be deducted from taxable turnover when the assessee purchased the goods from an unregistered dealer, though the goods had earlier suffered tax at the first stage.

Analysis: The provision deducted from taxable turnover the sale price of specified goods purchased otherwise than in the course of inter-State trade or commerce from a registered dealer, provided the sales by such registered dealer were taxable. The dispute turned on whether the expression "purchased from a registered dealer" meant the immediate seller to the assessee or the registered dealer at the first stage of sale. The Court held that the provision embodied the principle of single point taxation and had to be read consistently with that scheme. In that setting, the registered dealer need not be the immediate transferor if the goods had originally been purchased from a registered dealer at the first stage and tax had been paid accordingly. The earlier view taking a narrower meaning was not followed in light of the later Supreme Court interpretation of a similar single-point taxation scheme.

Conclusion: The sale price of the goods was deductible from taxable turnover, and the question was answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing provision reflects a single-point sales tax scheme, the expression identifying the registered dealer from whom goods were purchased may be construed to refer to the registered dealer at the first stage of sale, not necessarily the assessee's immediate seller.

---