1993 (1) TMI 264 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Court affirms classification of strips for fluorescent tubes under tax entry 92.

MK Industries Versus State of Gujarat

The High Court upheld the Gujarat Sales Tax Tribunal's decision to classify sales of strips used for fixing fluorescent tubes under entry 92 of the ... - Issues:Interpretation of entry 41 and entry 92 of the Gujarat Sales Tax Act, 1969 regarding the classification of electrical goods, specifically fluorescent tube accessories, under the appropriate entry for sales tax purposes.Detailed Analysis:The Gujarat Sales Tax Tribunal referred a question to the High Court regarding the classification of sales of strips used for fixing fluorescent tubes under entry 41 or entry 92 of Schedule II, Part A, to the Gujarat Sales Tax Act, 1969. The Tribunal concluded that the sales of strips fall under entry 92, covering fluorescent tubes, chokes, starters, fixtures, fittings, and accessories. The applicant contended that the strips should be considered electrical goods under entry 41, excluding goods specified in entry 92. The Tribunal rejected this argument, emphasizing that strips are fittings of fluorescent tubes and should be classified under entry 92 (paragraph 3).Entry 41 of the Act pertains to electrical goods excluding those specified in entry 92, while entry 92 includes fluorescent tubes, chokes, starters, fixtures, fittings, and accessories. The Court highlighted that the strips in question are used solely for fixing fluorescent tubes and are considered fittings of the tubes, aligning with the description in entry 92 (paragraph 6).The Court emphasized that interpreting sales tax entries requires considering common understanding and industry usage. It was noted that no one in the electric goods trade would classify only strips as electrical goods, supporting the classification of strips under entry 92. The Court also distinguished a prior case concerning fluorescent tubes without accessories, clarifying that entry 92 encompasses both the tubes and their components (paragraph 9).The Court concluded that the Tribunal's decision to classify the sales of strips under entry 92 was justified, as entry 92 is inclusive and covers fluorescent tubes along with their components and accessories. The use of the term 'including' in entry 92 indicates an expansive scope, encompassing various components related to fluorescent tubes (paragraph 11).In the final ruling, the Court answered the question in favor of the Revenue and against the assessee, affirming the Tribunal's decision to classify the sales of strips under entry 92 of the Gujarat Sales Tax Act, 1969 (paragraph 12).