Sales tax classification of muddagur as molasses upheld on commercial identity and settled precedent.

Muddagur retained the commercial and functional character of molasses despite being in solid form, because it was fit for alcohol manufacture and cattle fodder rather than human consumption as jaggery. The classification had already been settled by an earlier Division Bench treating it as molasses in solid form, and stare decisis supported maintaining that view. It was therefore taxable as molasses under the relevant sales tax entry, not as jaggery, and the revision cases failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether muddagur is taxable as jaggery under Entry 1 of Schedule V of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957, or as molasses under Entry 55 of Schedule I of that Act.

Analysis: The product was found, on the manufacturing process and commercial character, to be molasses converted into a solid form. It was held fit for use in making alcohol and as cattle fodder, not for human consumption as jaggery. An earlier Division Bench decision had already concluded that muddagur is nothing but molasses in solid form, and that view had been consistently followed for a long period. The principle of stare decisis weighed against reconsideration of that settled classification.

Conclusion: Muddagur was held taxable as molasses and not as jaggery.

Final Conclusion: The revision cases failed because the commodity was classified for sales tax purposes as molasses under the relevant tariff entry.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax classification, a product retains its taxable identity where its commercial and functional character shows it to be the same commodity in altered physical form, and long-settled precedent should not be disturbed absent compelling reason.

---