Optional post-sale warranty charges and sale price treatment under sales tax law depend on separate billing and factual proof.

Amounts charged for an optional, separately contracted post-sale warranty do not form part of the sale price under the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954, because sale price is limited to consideration for the sale and sums charged for matters done in respect of the goods at or before delivery. The tax treatment of such warranty charges, however, depends on proof that they were truly optional and separately billed. As the record did not conclusively establish those facts, the controversy required fresh factual examination on the nature of the charges.

---

---

Issues: Whether four-year warranty charges were includible in the sale price under the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954, and whether the matter required remand for factual verification of whether such charges were optional and separately charged.

Analysis: Section 2(p) of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954 limits sale price to the amount paid or payable as consideration for the sale, including further sums charged for anything done by the dealer in respect of the goods at or before delivery. On that footing, optional warranty charges for a later period stand on a different footing from the sale price if they are separately charged and relate to a future service obligation rather than to the transfer of the goods. At the same time, the record before the assessing authority was incomplete, and the factual position as to whether the warranty was truly optional and separately billed had not been properly established.

Conclusion: Four-year warranty charges are not part of the sale price if they are voluntary and separately charged, but the matter had to be sent back for a factual finding on those aspects.

Final Conclusion: The revision was allowed only to the extent of remitting the controversy for fresh examination on the nature of the warranty charges, without a final merits determination on inclusion in turnover.

Ratio Decidendi: Amounts charged for an optional, separately contracted post-sale warranty do not form part of sale price, but their tax treatment depends on proof of their optional and segregated character.

---