1990 (6) TMI 202 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

High Court allows appeal, overturns Revenue Board decision on stainless steel strips

The High Court of Madras allowed the appeals, setting aside the Board of Revenue's order and restoring the Appellate Assistant Commissioner's decision. ... - Issues:- Interpretation of tax assessment on stainless steel strips- Classification of goods under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax ActInterpretation of tax assessment on stainless steel strips:The case involved the tax assessment of stainless steel strips sold by the appellant, initially assessed at 8% but later revised to 13% based on the Intelligence Wing's report. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner determined that the strips did not qualify as motor parts and should be taxed at 8%. However, the Board of Revenue disagreed, considering the allotment order by the Director of Industries and classifying the strips as component parts of automobiles. The appellant argued that the strips could not be directly used as wiper blades and should not be taxed at 13%. The Court analyzed the nature of the strips and concluded that they were not standalone motor parts but rather raw materials for auto parts processing. The Board of Revenue's reliance on the allotment order was deemed incorrect, and the original assessment by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was upheld.Classification of goods under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act:The disagreement centered on whether the stainless steel strips sold by the appellant should be classified as component parts of automobiles under item 3 of the First Schedule to the Act or as articles of stainless steel under item 109. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner found that the strips were not motor parts but stainless steel articles, hence subject to 8% tax. Conversely, the Board of Revenue considered the allotment order and invoice descriptions to classify the strips as wiper arm blades, leading to a 13% tax assessment. The Court sided with the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, emphasizing that the strips were not sold as complete auto parts but as raw materials for further processing. This decision overturned the Board of Revenue's classification and restored the original assessment at 8% tax rate.In conclusion, the High Court of Madras allowed the appeals, setting aside the Board of Revenue's order and restoring the Appellate Assistant Commissioner's decision. The judgment clarified that the stainless steel strips in question were not component parts of automobiles but rather raw materials falling under item 109 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act.