Clarificatory reassessment power under sales tax law upheld for wrongly granted exemption and first-sale turnover.

Section 14(4)(cc) of the A.P. General Sales Tax Act was treated as clarificatory because the existing reassessment power already covered turnover that had escaped assessment or been under-assessed, including cases where exemption or deduction had been wrongly granted. The later insertion therefore did not create a new power but expressly reflected the pre-existing authority to assess the correct tax payable. On the facts, the reassessment was also supported by the record, which showed that the turnover constituted first sales within the State, so the reassessment was upheld in favour of the Revenue.

---

---

Issues: Whether section 14(4)(cc) of the A.P. General Sales Tax Act, 1957 was merely clarificatory and could be applied to reassessments made after its insertion in cases where exemption or deduction had been wrongly allowed; and whether the reassessment of the turnover as first sales was valid.

Analysis: The provision was inserted to deal expressly with cases where deduction or exemption had been wrongly granted. The body of section 14(4) already empowered the assessing authority to proceed where turnover had escaped assessment or had been under-assessed, and a wrongly granted exemption or deduction could fall within either category. On that basis, the later insertion of clause (cc) did not create a new power but only clarified the existing power to assess the correct tax payable. The reassessment was also supported by the material on record, which showed that the turnover represented first sales within the State.

Conclusion: Section 14(4)(cc) was held to be clarificatory, and the reassessment was upheld. The issue was decided in favour of the Revenue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a wrongly granted exemption or deduction is already covered by the pre-existing reassessment power in the escaped-assessment or under-assessment provisions, a later express insertion dealing with that situation is clarificatory and may be applied to sustain reassessment.

---