Bus body mounted on chassis treated as part of motor vehicle, confirming higher sales tax treatment

Bus bodies mounted on motor vehicle chassis were treated as component parts of the motor vehicle for the relevant sales tax entry. The court construed "components of motor vehicle" in the context of the entry covering motor vehicles, chassis, tyres, tubes and spare parts, and distinguished authorities treating bus bodies as separate finished goods on their facts. It accepted that a vehicle is not ordinarily complete or functional for conveyance without its body. On that reasoning, the sale of bus bodies mounted on chassis attracted tax at the higher rate, and the dealer's claim to the concessional rate failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether bus bodies mounted on motor vehicle chassis are component parts of motor vehicles under the relevant sales tax entry, and whether sale of such bus bodies attracts tax at 12 per cent rather than the concessional rate claimed by the dealer.

Analysis: The expression "components of motor vehicle" was construed in the context of the entry covering motor vehicles, chassis, tyres, tubes and spare parts. Earlier decisions of other High Courts were examined. Authorities treating bus bodies as separate finished goods were distinguished on their facts, while cases holding that bodies mounted on chassis are integral to the motor vehicle were treated as more apposite. The body of a motor vehicle was regarded as necessary for the vehicle to function as a conveyance, and a chassis by itself was not treated as a complete vehicle for the relevant purpose. On that reasoning, a bus body mounted on a chassis was held to be part of the motor vehicle.

Conclusion: The bus bodies mounted on chassis were held to be component parts of motor vehicles, and the higher rate of tax was held to be correctly applied; the questions were answered against the dealer and in favour of the Revenue.

Ratio Decidendi: For the purposes of the relevant sales tax entry, a bus body mounted on a chassis forms an integral component of the motor vehicle because the vehicle is not ordinarily complete or functional for its intended use without such body.

---