Separate commercial commodities after ginning: cotton seeds outside-state sale did not misuse the resale declaration.

Cotton and cotton seeds were treated as separate commercial commodities after ginning, and a declaration in form S.T. 17 for purchase of cotton for resale within Rajasthan was held not to extend to cotton seeds obtained through that process. Sale of the ginned cotton within the State complied with the declared purpose, while sale of the seeds outside the State did not amount to misuse of the declaration or failure to use the goods for the declared object. On that reasoning, penalty under section 16(1)(k) of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954 was not leviable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee breached the declaration in form S.T. 17 by selling cotton seeds outside the State so as to attract penalty under section 16(1)(k) of the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954.

Analysis: Cotton and cotton seeds are separate commercial commodities after ginning. The declaration was obtained for purchase of cotton for resale within Rajasthan, and the sale of ginned cotton within the State complied with that declaration. Cotton seeds, being a distinct product obtained by the manufacturing process of ginning, were not covered by the declaration for resale of cotton. Hence, sale of the seeds outside the State did not amount to misuse of the declaration or failure to use the goods for the declared purpose.

Conclusion: The assessee did not misuse the declaration and the penalty under section 16(1)(k) was not leviable.

---