Printed stationery tax treatment turns on whether the transaction produces finished goods or remains a works contract.

Printed stationery is taxed by examining the substance of the transaction: if the item remains paper with merely a printed heading, it is not treated as a finished commercial commodity, but if printing results in a distinct marketable article, tax may apply. Printed letter pads were treated as paper and not taxable, while visiting cards were treated as taxable finished goods. Vouchers, bills and similar printed articles depended on the contract evidence, including whether paper was supplied by the customer, whether paper and printing were separately agreed, and whether the arrangement was a composite works contract or a separate sale of paper with incidental printing or binding. Where the paper sale was separate, only the printing or binding component could fall within works contract treatment.

---

---

Issues: Whether printed stationery and allied printed materials such as letter pads, vouchers and bills supplied by a printing press were taxable sales as finished goods or were merely works contracts involving locally purchased paper.

Analysis: The applicable test was whether the substance of the transaction was a transfer of a finished commercial commodity or merely the exercise of skill and labour on material supplied or purchased for use in printing. Printed letter pads were treated as writing paper with a printed heading and therefore retained the character of paper. By contrast, visiting cards were treated as taxable finished goods. For vouchers, bills and similar printed articles, the decisive factors were whether the customer supplied paper, whether there was a separate agreement for paper and printing, and whether the transaction was really for supply of finished goods or a composite contract for work and sale. Where the sale of locally purchased paper was separate from printing or binding, the paper component was not taxable, while printing and binding charges could fall within a works contract.

Conclusion: Printed letter pads were held not taxable as they remained paper. Visiting cards were held taxable. Vouchers, bills and similar articles were held taxable or non-taxable depending on the nature of the contract and the evidence as to whether the transaction was a single sale of finished goods or a separate sale of paper with incidental printing or binding.

---