Sales tax classification of neon signs: electricity-assisted use alone does not make them electrical goods.

For sales tax classification, an article is not "electrical goods" merely because electricity enhances one mode of its use; it must, in substance, be one that cannot function without electrical energy. Applying that test, neon signs were held not to fall within entry No. 18 of the First Schedule to the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941, because they remained visible and commercially usable in daylight even without power, and their advertising function did not cease in the absence of electricity.

---

---

Issues: Whether neon signs sold by the assessee were covered by the expression "electrical goods" in entry No. 18 of the First Schedule to the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941.

Analysis: The article had to be classified according to its real commercial character and the sense in which the expression was used in sales tax law. Although the signs depended upon electricity for illumination at night, they remained usable and intelligible even without electricity, because the letters were visible in the daytime and did not cease to serve their advertising function when power was absent. Goods that are truly electrical are those which cannot function at all without electricity; the mere fact that an article uses electricity for one aspect of its utility does not necessarily make it an electrical good. Applying that test, the neon signs were not articles whose use was exclusively or essentially dependent on electrical energy.

Conclusion: The neon signs were not "electrical goods" and did not fall within entry No. 18.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax classification, an article is not "electrical goods" merely because electricity enhances one mode of its use; it must, in substance, be an article that cannot function as such without electrical energy.

---