Concessional sales tax for halwai products applied to chaat items sold in ordinary trade sense.

A sales tax notification granting a concessional rate to articles ordinarily prepared by halwais was held applicable to chaat preparations sold by the dealer. The expression "halwai" was given its ordinary, practical trade meaning because it was not defined, and items commonly sold at halwai shops, including papri, dahi, chatni, aalu-tikki, bhaturas, chhola and samosa, could fall within the concession. The beneficial object of the notification required a liberal construction, so the reduced rate could not be denied merely because the dealer also dealt in chaat preparations. The dealer's taxable turnover was therefore liable at 2 per cent, not 5 per cent.

---

---

Issues: Whether the notification granting a reduced sales tax rate to articles ordinarily prepared by halwais dealing exclusively in such articles applied to chaat preparations sold by the dealer, and whether the dealer's taxable turnover was exigible at the reduced rate of 2 per cent rather than 5 per cent.

Analysis: The notification extended the concessional rate to articles ordinarily prepared by halwais when sold by such dealers. The expression "halwai" was not defined and had to be understood in its ordinary and practical sense. On that basis, the Court held that chaat preparations such as papri, dahi, chatni, aalu-tikki, bhaturas, chhola, samosa and similar items were commonly available at halwai shops and could reasonably be treated as preparations ordinarily prepared by halwais. In view of the beneficial object of the notification, the concessional rate could not be denied merely because the dealer's business included chaat preparations.

Conclusion: The notification applied to the dealer, and the taxable turnover was correctly liable to tax at 2 per cent and not 5 per cent.

Final Conclusion: The reference was answered in favour of the assessee, and the concessional sales tax rate was held applicable to the dealer's chaat preparations.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a tax concession applies to articles ordinarily prepared by halwais, the expression must be given its ordinary trade sense, and articles commonly sold at halwai shops may qualify for the concessional rate even if not expressly defined as halwai products.

---