Turnover excludes separate sawing charges; purchase tax applies only to timber actually consumed, while a 5 per cent estimate stood.

Sawing charges collected under a separate and independent contract for cutting timber before delivery were not part of turnover under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, because only sums forming part of the sale consideration or integral to the sale contract are included. Purchase tax under section 5A applied only to the extent timber was consumed for conversion into sawn timber or scantlings, so the entire purchase turnover could not be taxed and the quantum required reconsideration. A 5 per cent estimate based on defects in the accounts was upheld as moderate and unsupported by grounds for interference.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether sawing charges collected by a timber dealer for sawing logs before delivery formed part of the turnover under the definition of turnover in the Kerala General Sales Tax Act; (ii) whether the entire purchase turnover of timber was liable to purchase tax under section 5A; (iii) whether the addition of 5 per cent by way of estimate called for interference.

Issue (i): whether sawing charges collected by a timber dealer for sawing logs before delivery formed part of the turnover under the definition of turnover in the Kerala General Sales Tax Act.

Analysis: The definition of turnover takes in the aggregate amount for which goods are bought or sold, and explanation (2)(i) includes sums charged for anything done by the dealer in respect of the goods sold at the time of or before delivery. That provision must be read in the context of the sale consideration itself. Charges for services rendered under the contract of sale, or otherwise forming part of the consideration for transfer of the goods, are included. But where there is a distinct and independent contract for services, the amount payable under that contract is not part of the sale price or turnover. On the facts accepted by the authorities, the sawing charges were under a separate contract subsequent to the sale and could not be treated as part of the turnover.

Conclusion: The sawing charges were not includible in turnover, and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (ii): whether the entire purchase turnover of timber was liable to purchase tax under section 5A.

Analysis: Timber purchased for conversion into sawn timber or scantlings may attract purchase tax only to the extent it is consumed for that taxable purpose. The Tribunal was right in rejecting the department's position that the entire purchase turnover was taxable, because part of the timber had been sold as logs. However, the exact quantum liable under section 5A required factual examination, and the Tribunal properly directed reconsideration of that figure.

Conclusion: The remand for fresh examination of the quantum taxable under section 5A was upheld.

Issue (iii): whether the addition of 5 per cent by way of estimate called for interference.

Analysis: Defects in the accounts were accepted by the authorities, and the estimate adopted was found to be moderate. No basis was shown to disturb that assessment.

Conclusion: The 5 per cent estimate was sustained.

Final Conclusion: Relief was confined to deletion of tax on the sawing charges, while the remaining assessment and the direction for reconsideration of the section 5A turnover were maintained.

Ratio Decidendi: A charge for work done before delivery forms part of turnover only when it is part of the sale consideration or an integral incident of the sale contract, and not when it arises under a separate and independent service contract.

---