Tax classification of filigree-decorated ornaments turned on specific entry over general entry, with personal-wear ornaments taxed at the lower rate.

Ornaments decorated with filigree work were construed as ornaments for personal wear rather than mere filigree work. Applying strict construction of taxing entries, harmonious interpretation of the competing schedules, the common parlance test, and the rule that a specific entry prevails over a general one, the goods were held to fall within the entry for bullion, specie, ornaments and articles made thereof. The applicable tax rate was therefore 2 per cent under serial No. 1, not 7 per cent under serial No. 32.

---

---

Issues: Whether ornaments decorated with filigree work were taxable at 2 per cent under serial No. 1 of the schedule of taxable goods or at 7 per cent under serial No. 32.

Analysis: The relevant entries had to be construed in the light of section 5 of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947 and the successive notifications amending the schedule. Serial No. 1, as amended for the relevant assessment year, covered bullion, specie, ornaments and other articles made thereof at 2 per cent. Serial No. 32 covered ornamental metal-ware with enamelled or carved designs and gold and silver filigrees, but retained language excluding ornaments of personal wear made of gold or silver. Applying strict construction of taxing entries, harmonious construction of the competing entries, the common parlance test, and the principle that a specific entry prevails over a general one, the basic character of the goods remained that of ornaments for personal wear and not mere filigree work.

Conclusion: The sale of ornaments decorated with filigree work fell under serial No. 1 and was taxable at 2 per cent, not under serial No. 32 at 7 per cent.

---