Revisional power cannot create an original penalty order where the assessing authority never imposed one.

The Madras High Court held that revisional powers under section 34 could be exercised only in relation to an order already passed by a subordinate authority. Because the assessing authority had neither expressly nor impliedly imposed penalty under section 12(3) at the assessment stage, there was no existing penalty order for the Board of Revenue to revise. The Board could correct or substitute an erroneous subordinate order, but it could not assume the original statutory function and create a fresh penalty order in revision. The penalty order was therefore without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Board of Revenue could, in exercise of suo motu revisional powers, itself levy penalty under section 12(3) when the assessing authority had not passed any order under that provision while making the assessment.

Analysis: Penalty under section 12(3) formed part of the assessment process, but revisional jurisdiction could be exercised only in respect of an order passed by a subordinate authority. The record showed that the assessing authority had neither expressly nor impliedly made any order under section 12(3) at the assessment stage. In the absence of any order levying penalty, there was nothing for the Board to revise. The Board could revise an existing erroneous order and substitute a proper one, but it could not assume the original statutory power which the assessing authority had not exercised. Section 34 also contemplated revision of an order already passed by a subordinate authority, whether express or implied.

Conclusion: The Board of Revenue had no jurisdiction to make an original order levying penalty under section 12(3) in revision, and the penalty order was liable to be set aside.

Ratio Decidendi: Revisional authority can act only on an order already passed by a subordinate authority, and cannot itself make an original assessment or penalty order that the assessing authority failed to make.

---