Film production agreement treated as service contract, with no transfer of property in goods and no sales tax liability.

An agreement for production of the Hindi version of a film was held to be a contract for service, not a sale exigible to tax under section 2 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act. The producer retained ownership and the right to exploit the finished cinematographic film, while the assessee merely undertook production work, arranged staff and materials, and delivered the censored negatives on completion. Supplying raw film and carrying out the production process did not amount to transfer of property in goods or create any element of sale. The transaction was therefore outside sales tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether the agreement for production of the Hindi version of a film amounted to a sale exigible to tax under section 2 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, or only a contract for service.

Analysis: The agreement showed that the producer retained the right to exploit and own the finished cinematographic film, while the assessee was to provide production services, arrange staff and materials, and deliver the censored negatives after completion. The fact that the assessee supplied raw film and undertook the production work did not create a transfer of property in goods or any element of sale. On the terms of the arrangement, the assessee acted only as a facilitator in bringing about the finished product for the producer.

Conclusion: The agreement was a service contract and not a sale; the transaction was not taxable as a sale under section 2 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act.

---