Escapement of assessment permits reassessment where original order shows no conscious finding on taxable turnover.

Where an original assessment did not disclose any conscious decision excluding hire-purchase turnover from tax, the omission amounted to escapement of turnover within section 16(1) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The Madras HC held that a note in the file could not override the assessment order, and since the taxable turnover had not been brought to charge on the face of the assessment, reassessment was within jurisdiction. The court found it unnecessary to decide the broader question whether section 16 could also apply where taxability had earlier been consciously decided against the revenue. The reassessment challenge therefore failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether reassessment under section 16 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1959 was valid where turnover had escaped assessment in the original order.

Analysis: The original assessment order did not show any conscious adjudication excluding the hire-purchase turnover from tax. A note in the file could not override the assessment order itself. On the face of the assessment, the assessing authority accepted the return without bringing the entire taxable turnover to charge. That amounted to escapement of tax within the meaning of section 16(1). The reassessment was therefore within jurisdiction, and it was unnecessary to decide the broader question whether section 16 could be invoked where the officer had earlier consciously decided the taxability against the revenue.

Conclusion: Reassessment under section 16(1) was valid and the challenge to the reassessment failed.

Final Conclusion: The revision succeeded because the turnover had escaped assessment and the department was entitled to reopen and reassess the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the original assessment does not disclose a conscious decision on the taxability of particular turnover, omission to assess that turnover constitutes escapement of assessment and can be corrected by reassessment under the statutory escapement provision.

---