Common parlance classification of Menthol crystals as Mint supported export cess liability and defeated pre-deposit relief.

Menthol BP/USP Crystals were discussed as potentially classifiable as "Mint" for export cess purposes under the Spices Cess Act, with classification informed by ordinary meaning and common parlance. The materials noted that the goods were manufactured from peppermint and crystallised from peppermint oil, and that the Spices Board and the Ministry of Commerce had treated the commodity as "Mint". On that basis, no prima facie case against the cess demand was shown. Relief from pre-deposit was also declined because financial hardship was not pleaded, and prior provisional clearance against bank guarantee did not eliminate the pre-deposit requirement.

---

---

Issues: Whether Menthol BP/USP Crystals were liable to Export Cess as "Mint" under Section 3 of the Spices Cess Act, 1986, and whether waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery could be granted.

Analysis: The expression "Mint" was treated as an undefined commodity and its ordinary meaning was applied. On the materials placed, the goods were manufactured from peppermint and crystallised from peppermint oil, and the common parlance understanding of the term was relevant for classification. The record also showed that the commodity had been viewed by the Spices Board and the Ministry of Commerce as "Mint". In these circumstances, the appellants did not establish a prima facie case against the demand of cess. As financial hardship was not pleaded, and the earlier provisional clearance against bank guarantee did not by itself negate liability to pre-deposit, relief from deposit was not justified.

Conclusion: The application for waiver of pre-deposit and stay was rejected in substance, and the appellant was directed to pre-deposit Rs. 50,00,000 under Section 129E of the Customs Act.

---