Newspaper classification for sales tax turns on essential character, and a law report-style journal was held outside the exemption.

For sales tax purposes, a periodical qualifies as a newspaper only if its essential character is the dissemination of public news or comments on public news. A publication whose dominant character is a law report or book of reference, intended for citation and containing authoritative reports of decisions, does not become a newspaper merely because it is issued periodically, includes current notes or advertisements, or is registered as a newspaper under other laws. On that basis, the monthly law journal was held not to be a newspaper and was not entitled to exemption from sales tax.

---

---

Issues: Whether the monthly law journal entitled Cuttack Law Times was a newspaper so as to qualify for exemption from sales tax under the Orissa Sales Tax Act.

Analysis: The constitutional scheme distinguished newspapers from other goods: sales tax could be levied on goods other than newspapers, while newspapers were placed within the Union field for taxation. The Court examined the ordinary meaning of newspaper and the statutory definitions in several enactments, all of which pointed to a periodical containing public news or comments on public news. A publication whose dominant character is that of a book of reference, intended for citation in courts and containing authoritative reports of decisions, does not answer that description merely because it appears periodically or contains some current notes, comments, or advertisements. Registration as a newspaper under other statutes was held not to control the meaning of the term for sales tax purposes.

Conclusion: The publication was not a newspaper and was therefore not entitled to exemption from sales tax.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax purposes, a periodical qualifies as a newspaper only if its essential character is the dissemination of public news or comments on public news; a publication primarily serving as a law report or book of reference is not a newspaper merely because it is periodically issued or registered as such under other laws.

---