Inconsistent findings on delivery of goods can vitiate sales tax assessment where exemption depends on the place of delivery.

An assessment order is vitiated when it records internally inconsistent findings on the material facts governing tax liability and exemption. Here, the disputed sales turned on whether delivery occurred within West Bengal or outside it for purposes of exemption under section 5(2)(a)(v) of the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941. Because the order appeared to accept that the goods were brought into West Bengal by purchasers while also denying exemption on the footing that delivery occurred in West Bengal, it failed to disclose a clear and consistent finding on the jurisdictional fact. The defective assessment was quashed in part and remitted for reconsideration of the exemption claim.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessment order was liable to be quashed for containing inconsistent findings regarding the place of delivery of goods and the availability of exemption under section 5(2)(a)(v) of the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941.

Analysis: The notice and revised return raised the question whether the disputed sales were completed outside West Bengal or whether the goods were delivered in West Bengal so as to affect liability to sales tax and the claim to exemption. The assessment order recorded findings that were mutually inconsistent: it appeared to accept that the goods were brought into West Bengal by the purchasers, yet the exemption claim was disallowed on the footing that the goods were delivered in West Bengal. Such a finding could not stand because the order failed to disclose a clear and consistent determination on the material jurisdictional fact governing exemption and taxability.

Conclusion: The assessment order was quashed in part and the matter was remitted to the Commercial Tax Officer for reconsideration of the exemption claim and for a clear finding on whether the goods were delivered within West Bengal or outside it.

Final Conclusion: The petitioner succeeded to the extent of obtaining quashing of the defective assessment order and a remand for fresh decision on the disputed exemption issue, while the unchallenged remainder of the assessment was left undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi: An assessment order containing internally inconsistent findings on the material facts governing tax liability and statutory exemption is vitiated and may be quashed with a direction for reconsideration on those facts.

---