Sales tax classification of biscuits turns on commercial parlance and the scope of the cakes, pastries and sweetmeats exception.

Biscuits were analysed under the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 as cooked food because they are baked by heat, but they were treated as distinct from bread for sales tax classification. The exemption for cakes, pastries and sweetmeats was construed by ordinary market understanding: the relevant test was whether the goods are known and sold under the excluded name. On that basis, biscuits were not regarded as cakes, pastries or sweetmeats in commercial parlance and therefore remained within the taxable description. The commentary notes an exception for biscuits sold in sealed containers, which were treated separately for assessment purposes.

---

---

Issues: Whether biscuits were liable to sales tax under the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941, and whether they fell within the taxable entry for cooked foods or within the exception for cakes, pastries and sweetmeats.

Analysis: The Schedule under section 6 of the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 governed the question. Bread and biscuits were treated as different commodities, so the entry relating to bread did not apply. Biscuits were nevertheless cooked foods because they are baked by application of heat. The remaining question was whether they were excluded by the exception for cakes, pastries and sweetmeats. In determining the scope of the exception, the practical test adopted was whether the commodity is known and sold in the market under the name used in the exception. Biscuits were not cakes, pastries or sweetmeats in ordinary commercial understanding, and a purchaser asking for cakes or pastries would not receive biscuits as the same commodity.

Conclusion: Biscuits were held to be cooked food falling within the taxable schedule entry, but not within the exception for cakes, pastries and sweetmeats; however, biscuits sold in sealed containers remained outside the exempted category and were taxable accordingly.

Final Conclusion: The assessment had to be revised by excluding the sale of biscuits from the taxable turnover, except for biscuits sold in sealed containers.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a taxing entry contains an exception for specified commodities, the exception applies only if the goods are identifiable and known in the market by the excluded name; goods not so known remain within the general taxable description.

---