Territorial nexus in sales tax: business carried on where sale contracts are habitually made, despite residence elsewhere.

A person may be treated as carrying on business within a taxing territory for sales tax purposes even if the principal place of business is elsewhere, where the contracts constituting the substance of the trade are habitually made in that territory and the sales have the required territorial nexus. Here, the contracts of sale were executed in Fort Cochin, the goods were delivered there, and the transactions were not confined to the appellant's residence or principal office. The appellant was therefore held to be a dealer within section 2(b) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939, and the assessment was upheld.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the appellant, whose principal place of business was outside the Province of Madras, could nevertheless be regarded as carrying on the business of buying or selling goods in Madras so as to fall within the definition of a dealer under the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939, and be liable to assessment on the sales effected in Fort Cochin.

Analysis: The decisive test was where the contracts forming the essence of the business were habitually made. The appellant's contracts of sale were executed in Fort Cochin by him or his son, the goods were delivered to buyers in Fort Cochin, and the transactions were therefore not confined to the location of the appellant's residence or principal office. The Court applied the settled principle that a person may carry on business in a taxing territory even though resident elsewhere, if the profit-earning contracts are made there and the transactions have the necessary territorial connection with that area.

Conclusion: The appellant was a dealer within section 2(b) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939, and the assessment under the Act was valid.

Final Conclusion: The suit challenge to the sales tax assessment failed, and the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi: For sales tax purposes, a person carries on business within a taxing territory when the contracts constituting the substance of the trade are habitually made there and the sales transactions have the requisite territorial nexus, even if the person's residence or principal place of business is outside that territory.

---