Prima facie classification of composite product justified unconditional waiver of pre-deposit in a tax dispute.

In a classification dispute over a composite product comprising a sugar cone placed inside an aluminium foil cone, the tribunal treated the issue as one of prima facie classification for interim relief. It noted that the sugar cone was separately classifiable under Chapter 19 and the aluminium foil cone under Chapter 76, and that enclosing the sugar cone in the foil sleeve did not, on a preliminary view, convert the product into an aluminium container. The prior acceptance of the assessee's classification by the adjudicating authority also supported relief. On that basis, unconditional waiver of pre-deposit was granted and the stay application was allowed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant had made out a case for dispensing with pre-deposit of duty and penalty pending appeal in a dispute concerning classification of a composite product consisting of a sugar cone placed in an aluminium foil cone.

Analysis: The dispute was confined to the classification of the composite product. The sugar cones, when cleared separately, were already treated as classifiable under Chapter 19, and the aluminium foil cones, when separately cleared, were classifiable under Chapter 76. On a prima facie view, placing the sugar cone inside its aluminium sleeve did not transform the product into an aluminium container. The adjudicating authority had originally accepted the assessee's position, and that factor also supported the assessee at the interim stage. The balance of convenience was therefore considered to be in favour of granting relief from pre-deposit.

Conclusion: The appellant was entitled to unconditional waiver of pre-deposit and the stay application was allowed.

---