Cenvat credit on dumpers used for limestone transport was prima facie denied, with only reduced pre-deposit relief granted.

Dumpers used to transport limestone from the mines to the crushing area were examined for Cenvat credit eligibility as inputs, but the Tribunal's prima facie view was that they were not integrally connected with the manufacturing process in the manner required for input treatment. The assessee's reliance on exemption and sales tax authorities was distinguished, and its own treatment of the dumpers as capital goods with depreciation claimed was noted against its case. On the question of pre-deposit, the absence of financial hardship weighed against a complete waiver, so only partial relief by way of reduced pre-deposit was granted.

---

---

Issues: Whether dumpers used for transporting limestone from the mines to the crushing area could be treated as inputs for Cenvat credit, and whether total waiver of pre-deposit was warranted.

Analysis: The exemption under Notification No. 217/86-C.E. was considered in the context of inputs used within the factory in relation to manufacture, but the reasoning relied upon by the assessee was found to arise from a different exclusion clause and from sales tax decisions dealing with goods used in manufacture, mining, or processing. The Tribunal formed a prima facie view that dumpers used for carrying inputs were not integrally connected with the manufacturing process in the manner necessary to qualify as inputs, and noted that the assessee itself had treated the dumpers as capital goods and claimed depreciation. In the absence of financial hardship, the Tribunal found no basis for complete waiver of the dues.

Conclusion: The dumpers were not accepted, prima facie, as inputs for the purpose of complete waiver, and only partial relief by way of reduced pre-deposit was granted.

---