Excise exemption on spent sulphuric acid fails where scrap terms and captive consumption conditions are not strictly met.

Spent sulphuric acid arising in the manufacture of acid slurry was held outside the scope of the claimed excise exemptions. The benefit under Notification No. 89/95-C.E. was confined to scrap arising in the manufacture of specified goods and did not extend to waste and scrap generated in a factory producing other non-exempt goods. The claim under Notification No. 88/88-C.E. also failed because the material was not accepted as goods captively consumed in the manufacture of detergent cake or detergent powder, and its clearance from the factory showed that the captive-consumption condition was not satisfied. The exemption claim was therefore rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether Spent Sulphuric Acid arising in the manufacture of Acid Slurry was eligible for exemption under Notification No. 89/95-C.E. dated 18-05-1995 or Notification No. 88/88-C.E. dated 01-03-1988.

Analysis: The claim under Notification No. 89/95-C.E. failed because the benefit was confined to scrap arising in the manufacture of specified goods and did not extend to waste and scrap arising in a factory where other than exempted goods were also manufactured. The claim under Notification No. 88/88-C.E. also failed because the Spent Acid was not accepted as goods consumed in the manufacture of detergent cake and detergent powder, and the clearance of the material from the factory showed that the condition of captive consumption within the manufacturer's factory or another eligible factory was not satisfied.

Conclusion: The exemption under both notifications was not available and the claim was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The appeals failed as the disputed product did not satisfy the conditions of the claimed exemption notifications.

Ratio Decidendi: Exemption based on captive consumption is unavailable where the material is cleared from the factory and the notification conditions are not strictly fulfilled, and waste or scrap benefits cannot be extended beyond the terms of the exemption notification.

---