Prima facie stay relief and handicrafts certification under duty-free import notification; Revenue's challenge failed

On a prima facie review of the Revenue's stay request concerning duty-free import under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus., the Export Promotion Council for Handicrafts certificate was treated as significant, and the Revenue failed to produce clear material to discredit it. The cited Supreme Court ruling in Louis Shoppe was considered of limited relevance because it arose under a different notification. In the absence of a clear and dependable definition of "handicrafts" and without convincing proof to disturb the certificate, no interim interference was warranted, and the stay application was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Revenue's stay application in the appeal concerning duty-free import under Notification No. 21/2002-Cus. should be granted.

Analysis: The request for stay was examined on a prima facie basis. The certificate issued by the Export Promotion Council for Handicrafts was treated as significant at this stage, and the Revenue had not produced clear material to discredit it. The reliance placed on the Supreme Court decision in Louis Shoppe was found to be of limited relevance because it was rendered in the context of a different notification. In the absence of a clear and dependable definition of "handicrafts" and without convincing proof to disturb the certificate, no interim interference was warranted.

Conclusion: The Revenue was not entitled to stay, and the stay application was rejected.

---