Confiscation and penalty under excise rules fail where intent to evade duty and factual foundations are not established.

Confiscation under Rule 173Q was found unsustainable because the record did not show clearance of goods with intent to evade duty, and the appellate order rested on factual errors, including reference to penalties and redemption fine not imposed by the original authority. The Tribunal also noted that the assessee claimed small scale industry exemption and that the record did not show the SSI limit had been crossed. A penalty, if any, was treated as doubtful on the available facts and might at most have arisen under Rule 226 for record-keeping lapses. The appellate order was set aside and rectification was allowed, granting relief to the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the penalty and confiscation order could be sustained where the appellate order proceeded on incorrect facts, the show cause notice and findings did not support confiscation for duty evasion, and the assessee claimed exemption as a small scale industry.

Analysis: The Tribunal found a mistake apparent on the face of the record in its earlier observation that the only grievance was against penalty, because the appeal also challenged confiscation and the absence of redemption fine. On merits, the impugned appellate order was found to contain glaring factual errors, including reference to redemption fine and personal penalty not imposed by the original authority. The Tribunal held that confiscation under Rule 173Q was not justified in the absence of a finding that the goods were cleared with intent to evade duty. It further noted that the assessee claimed small scale industry exemption and that, on the record, there was no finding that the SSI limit had already been crossed. The suggestion that a penalty could at best arise under Rule 226 for failure to maintain records was also treated as doubtful in the circumstances.

Conclusion: The appellate order was set aside and the rectification application was allowed, resulting in relief to the assessee.

---