Modvat credit on manufacturing waste need not be reversed when inputs are wasted or rejected during production, with related penalty and interest falling away.

Modvat credit was not required to be reversed where inputs were issued for manufacture and were wasted or rejected during the manufacturing process, because waste arising after commencement of manufacture was treated as within the scheme's permissible credit treatment. The denial of credit therefore failed. As the penalty and interest were founded on the same credit demand, they could not survive once the principal reversal issue was decided against the department.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit was reversible when the inputs were wasted or rejected during the manufacturing process, and whether the related penalty and interest could survive.

Analysis: Credit was denied on the footing that the input was cleared as waste and was only on-line waste. The deciding consideration was that the inputs had been issued for manufacture and were wasted or rejected during the course of manufacture. On that footing, the situation was treated as covered by the principle that waste arising after commencement of the manufacturing process does not require reversal of credit under the Modvat scheme. The penalty and interest were linked to the same demand and therefore stood with the principal credit issue.

Conclusion: Modvat credit was not required to be reversed for the waste generated during manufacture, and the denial of credit failed. The penalty and interest also could not survive.

---