SSI declaration may satisfy return-filing for settlement admission when statutory conditions are otherwise met.

An SSI unit's declaration of intended exemption and disclosure of clearance position can satisfy the return-filing condition for admission of a settlement application where the statutory settlement requirements are otherwise met. The Commission treated the declaration as sufficient compliance because SSI units are not required to file returns until they cross the prescribed value limit. As the admitted duty liability exceeded the statutory threshold and the declaration had already been filed before detection, the applications were held admissible and allowed to proceed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the settlement applications were admissible under the statutory conditions for settlement, particularly the requirement of filing returns showing production, clearance and duty paid in the prescribed manner.

Analysis: The applicants had filed a declaration indicating availment of small scale industry exemption and the relevant clearance position before detection, though the formal returns were not filed within time. The Commission treated the declaration as sufficient compliance in the case of an SSI unit, noting that such units are not required to file returns until they cross the prescribed value limit. Since the admitted duty liability exceeded the statutory threshold and the requisite declaration had been filed, the conditions for admission were satisfied.

Conclusion: The settlement applications were admissible and were allowed to proceed.

Ratio Decidendi: For an SSI unit, a declaration of intended availment of exemption may constitute sufficient compliance with the return-filing requirement for admission of a settlement application when the statutory conditions for settlement are otherwise fulfilled.

---