Incomplete air-conditioner assemblies cannot be treated as complete machines when an essential component is missing at clearance.

An assembly cannot be classified as a complete air-conditioner where it lacks an essential component identified in the applicable departmental circular, including the capillary line. Goods must be assessed as presented at the time of clearance, and later aggregation of items cleared at different times cannot be used to treat them as a complete machine. An adjudication is also vitiated where it relies on facts and periods not covered by the relevant notices. On these grounds, the demand of duty and penalties based on misclassification were held unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the goods cleared by the assessee were classifiable as complete air-conditioners or as parts and components, and whether the duty demand and penalties were sustainable.

Analysis: The clearances were examined in the light of the Board's circular prescribing the essential components of an air-conditioning machine, including the capillary line. The Tribunal noted that the assessee's clearances did not include that essential component and that the adjudicating authority had ignored the circular despite earlier remand directions. It further held that the goods had to be assessed as presented at the time of clearance and not on the basis that multiple items cleared at different times could later be aggregated into a complete machine. The adjudicating order was also found to be vitiated by reliance on facts and periods not covered by the relevant notices.

Conclusion: The goods were not liable to be treated as complete air-conditioners, and the demand of duty and penalties could not be sustained.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order was set aside and the assessee succeeded in the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an assembly lacks an essential component identified by the applicable departmental circular, it cannot be classified as a complete machine and duty demand based on such misclassification is unsustainable.

---