Tariff classification evidence governs exemption claims when the Revenue cannot displace the existing classification of goods.

In tariff classification disputes, the party seeking to displace an existing classification must produce evidence of the goods' character and dimensions. The Revenue did not establish that bazaar scrap and spring leaves were classifiable as angles, shapes and sections under Chapter 72, because the necessary factual basis to disturb the original classification was absent. On that footing, the denial of exemption under the relevant notification was upheld, as the exemption claim depended on the classification position. The appellate authority's modification of the original order was therefore treated as legally proper, and the classification view adopted below was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether bazaar scrap and spring leaves were classifiable as waste and scrap or as angles, shapes and sections under Chapter 72, and whether the assessee was entitled to the benefit of the exemption notification.

Analysis: The Revenue failed to produce evidence showing the dimensions and character of the goods to establish classification as angles, shapes and sections, or to show that the goods fell within the exclusionary treatment under the relevant chapter note. The appellate authority's finding that the necessary factual basis for disturbing the original classification was absent was upheld. On that footing, the denial of exemption was also found justified, and the modification made to the original order was held to be legally proper.

Conclusion: The classification view adopted by the appellate authority was sustained, and the claim for exemption did not succeed.

Final Conclusion: Both appeals failed because the Revenue did not establish a basis to upset the existing classification, and the exemption relief was not available on the record.

Ratio Decidendi: In tariff classification disputes, the party seeking to displace the existing classification must adduce evidence sufficient to establish the goods' proper character and dimensions; absent such proof, exemption dependent on the classification cannot be granted.

---