Rule 57CC and bagasse clearance: strong prima facie case justified complete waiver of pre-deposit.

Rule 57CC was examined in relation to clearance of bagasse treated as a by-product without duty. The Tribunal noted that an earlier decision holding that no demand could be raised under Rule 57CC for bagasse had been taken to the Supreme Court and the appeal was dismissed. It also found that the contrary High Court decision cited by the Revenue did not address the precise issue raised. On that basis, the appellant was held to have a strong prima facie case, and waiver of the entire pre-deposit of duty and penalty was granted pending appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant was entitled to waiver of pre-deposit of the disputed duty and penalty pending appeal.

Analysis: The dispute concerned applicability of Rule 57CC to bagasse, treated by the appellant as a by-product cleared without duty. The Tribunal noted that an earlier decision holding that no demand could be raised under Rule 57CC for clearance of bagasse had been carried in appeal to the Supreme Court and the appeal had been dismissed. In view of that position and the fact that the contrary High Court decision cited by the Revenue did not consider the precise issue now raised, the appellant was found to have a strong prima facie case.

Conclusion: Waiver of the entire pre-deposit of duty and penalty was granted in favour of the appellant.

---