Tribunal Waives Duty & Penalty, Requires Deposit for Export Obligations

The Tribunal granted the application for waiver of pre-deposit of duty and penalty, condoning the delay in filing the Appeal due to the shifting of the Advocate's office. The Tribunal emphasized the Advocate's affidavit as evidence of the delay cause. The Tribunal directed the Applicants to deposit Rs. 22 lakhs within six weeks for verification of documents supporting export obligations fulfillment under the Advance Licence Scheme. Upon compliance, the remaining duty and penalty would be waived, with recovery stayed during the appeal's pendency. Failure to comply would result in automatic dismissal of the Appeal. Compliance reporting was set for 20-10-2004.

---

---

Issues: Application for waiver of pre-deposit of duty and penalty due to delay in filing the Appeal, compliance with conditions of Advance Licence Scheme, verification of documents for export obligation fulfillment.

In this case, M/s. God Gift Export House filed an application for waiver of pre-deposit of duty amounting to Rs. 59,27,988/- and equivalent penalty, citing a delay in filing the Appeal due to the shifting of their Advocate's office. The Advocate submitted an affidavit explaining the delay, leading to a request for condonation of the delay. The Senior Departmental Representative opposed the condonation, questioning the lack of specific details regarding the shifting date. The Tribunal, after considering both sides, condoned the delay and allowed the application, emphasizing the Advocate's affidavit as evidence of the delay cause.

Regarding compliance with the conditions of the Advance Licence Scheme, the Advocate for the Appellants argued that they had fulfilled the export obligation by exporting goods worth Rs. 86,18,509/-, manufactured from the raw material imported under the scheme. Documents supporting the export and realization of export proceeds were presented. However, the Senior Departmental Representative contended that the lack of response to the show cause notice and the cancellation of the advance licence by JDGFT raised doubts about the fulfillment of obligations. The Tribunal agreed that the documents needed verification before consideration, directing the Applicants to deposit Rs. 22 lakhs within six weeks. Upon compliance, the remaining duty and penalty would be waived, with recovery stayed during the appeal's pendency. Failure to comply would lead to automatic dismissal of the Appeal without further notice, with a compliance reporting set for 20-10-2004.

---