Accessory classification for refrigerator tops preserved small-scale exemption where the goods were not essential refrigerator parts.

Wooden laminated tops manufactured separately for refrigerators were treated as accessories, not essential components, because a refrigerator remained complete and functional without them. On that basis, they were not classifiable as parts of refrigerators. The classification also could not be used to withdraw the benefit of small-scale exemption where nothing indicated a legislative intention to deny that relief merely because the goods were later brought within a new tariff structure. The result stated is that manufacturers of such tops were entitled to small-scale exemption.

---

---

Issues: Whether wooden laminated tops manufactured independently for use on refrigerators were classifiable as parts of refrigerators, and whether their classification as such could deny the benefit of small-scale exemption.

Analysis: The tops were manufactured separately by a carpenter and were fixed on the refrigerator only at the top. The record showed that a refrigerator remained complete and functional without such tops, and the goods had earlier been treated as articles of wood rather than refrigerator parts. On the nature of the product, the tops were more in the character of accessories than essential components. The classification approach also had to be consistent with the pre-existing exemption position, and nothing showed a legislative intention to withdraw small-scale exemption from such manufacturers merely because the goods were later sought to be treated as refrigerator parts under the new tariff structure.

Conclusion: The goods were not parts of refrigerators and the assessees were entitled to the benefit of small-scale exemption.

Ratio Decidendi: A product that is independently manufactured and is only an optional accessory, not an essential component needed for a refrigerator to be complete, cannot be classified as a part of the refrigerator so as to deny small-scale exemption.

---