Excise duty on factory-made pipes cleared for pipeline use upheld, with penalty sustained but reduced on the facts.

Excise duty was held payable on pipes manufactured in a factory and cleared to the site for use in laying and embedding a pipeline, because the cited circular was confined to fabrication at site and did not cover goods first manufactured and then transported for installation. Clearance without payment of duty and without obtaining the required licence justified penalty under the excise rules. The penalty was upheld in principle, but the quantum was reduced on the facts and circumstances. The demand of duty and the finding of penal liability were sustained, with only the penalty amount moderated.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether duty was payable on pipes manufactured in the factory and cleared to the site for use in laying and embedding the pipeline; (ii) whether the penalty imposed under the excise rules was sustainable and, if so, to what extent.

Issue (i): Whether duty was payable on pipes manufactured in the factory and cleared to the site for use in laying and embedding the pipeline.

Analysis: The pipes were manufactured in the factory and removed to the site without payment of duty. The circular relied upon by the appellant was held to be inapplicable because the case concerned goods manufactured first and then transported for use in the pipeline, rather than fabrication at site in the manner contemplated by the circular.

Conclusion: Duty was payable on the pipes and the demand was upheld.

Issue (ii): Whether the penalty imposed under the excise rules was sustainable and, if so, to what extent.

Analysis: The clearance of the goods without payment of duty and without obtaining licence justified imposition of penalty. At the same time, the overall facts and circumstances warranted moderation of the quantum.

Conclusion: Penalty was upheld in principle but reduced to Rs. 2.5 lakhs.

Final Conclusion: The demand of duty and the finding of penal liability were sustained, with only the quantum of penalty being reduced.

Ratio Decidendi: Excise duty is payable on goods manufactured in a factory and removed without payment of duty for use at site, and where such removal is without disclosure or licence, penalty may be imposed though its quantum can be moderated on the facts.

---