Classification of spice-based digestive tablets turned on commercial identity and essential character as a condiment.

Digestive tablets made from a mixture of spices were held not to fall under the spice heading because they did not retain the essential character of spices in common parlance or trade. The products were manufactured as tablets, marketed as digestive preparations, and were not used in cooking or as condiments. Classification therefore followed their commercial identity rather than the mere presence of spice ingredients, and the residuary heading for edible preparations applied instead of the specific spice entry.

---

---

Issues: Whether the disputed digestive tablets and similar preparations, though made from a mixture of spices, were classifiable as spices under Chapter Heading 9.03 or as edible preparations under Chapter Heading 2108.99.

Analysis: Chapter Note 3 to Chapter 9 covers spices that are mainly used as condiments, whether whole or in crushed or powdered form, and mixtures retain that entry only if they keep the essential character of spices. The products were manufactured by grinding, mixing and moisturising ingredients into tablets and were marketed as digestive tablets, not as spices. Mere presence of spice ingredients did not make the finished products spices, because they were not used in cooking or as condiments and had no integral relation to food preparation or consumption as condiments. Their classification had to follow their commercial identity in trade and common parlance, and the residuary heading became applicable because they were not classifiable under the specific spice entry.

Conclusion: The products were not classifiable under Chapter Heading 9.03 and were classifiable under Chapter Heading 2108.99, in favour of the Revenue.

Final Conclusion: The classification adopted by the appellate authority was unsustainable, and the Revenue's classification under the residuary heading was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: A product made from spices is not classifiable as spices unless, in common parlance and trade understanding, it retains the essential character of a condiment used in food preparation or consumption.

---