Health tonic classification turns on product presentation: a general wellness formulation was placed under Chapter 21, not medicament rules.

Pentatone liquid, a mixture of vitamins, salts, iron and calcium, was treated as a health tonic rather than a medicament because its label described general health and prophylactic use, without showing it was marketed as a licensed medicine or intended to cure any ailment. The HSN note to Chapter 21 was applied to preparations put up for maintaining general health and well-being, leading to classification under Chapter 21 instead of Chapter 30. The claim for patent and proprietary medicament classification was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether the product, pentatone liquid, was classifiable under Chapter 30 as a patent and proprietary medicament or under Chapter 21 as a miscellaneous edible preparation/food preparation not elsewhere specified.

Analysis: The product was a mixture of vitamins, salts, iron and calcium and its label described it as a good health tonic, with dosage directions for general use and a claim of prophylactic use. The label did not indicate that it was a medicament, nor did it show manufacture as a licensed medicine. The HSN clarificatory note to Chapter 21 covers preparations put up with indications that they maintain general health or well-being. On the material on record, the product was viewed as advertised for good health rather than for curing any ailment.

Conclusion: The product was held classifiable under Chapter 21 and not under Chapter 30, and the assessee's claim for classification as a patent and proprietary medicine was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: A preparation presented as a health tonic for maintaining general well-being, without indications that it is a medicament, is classifiable under Chapter 21 rather than as a medicament under Chapter 30.

---