Court approves amalgamation scheme for five companies; dismisses objections, sets conditions for shareholder and creditor approval.

The court approved the scheme of amalgamation involving five companies after unanimous approval from shareholders and creditors. The Official Liquidator's objections were dismissed, emphasizing their limited role in the absence of a winding-up petition. Judicial precedents highlighted the importance of shareholder approval and established that objections based on account book inspection cannot impede the process. The court imposed specific conditions for approval, emphasizing the need for proper documentation, compliance with tax obligations, and legal liabilities post-amalgamation.

---

---

Issues Involved:
Petition for sanctioning the scheme of amalgamation under section 394 read with rule 79 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Approval of Shareholders and Creditors:
The petition was filed for sanctioning the scheme of amalgamation involving five companies. Meetings of shareholders and creditors were convened as per court direction, where all shareholders unanimously approved the resolution for amalgamation. Creditors also did not raise any objections to the scheme. The Regional Director, Ministry of Corporate Affairs, submitted a report without objections to the scheme.

2. Role of Official Liquidator:
The Official Liquidator requested copies of account books to file objections, which was opposed by the companies' counsel. The counsel argued that the Official Liquidator has no locus standi to oppose the amalgamation under section 394(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956. Reference was made to a Calcutta High Court judgment emphasizing that the Official Liquidator's role is limited when no winding up petition is presented. The judgment highlighted that the Official Liquidator cannot challenge the amalgamation if an application under section 394(1)(iv) is filed.

3. Judicial Precedents:
The counsel for the Official Liquidator cited a Supreme Court judgment, but the court differentiated the case, stating it did not address the dissolution aspect in the present case. Referring to a Madhya Pradesh High Court judgment, it was established that once shareholders unanimously approve the amalgamation scheme, objections by the Official Liquidator based on account book inspection cannot hinder the process. The court noted that the Company Law Board and creditors had also approved the scheme.

4. Conditions for Approval:
The court approved the amalgamation scheme with specific conditions. It clarified that the approval does not negate the requirement for proper documentation for transferring assets and rights. Additionally, it stated that the approval does not exempt companies or shareholders from capital gains tax liabilities or breach of laws committed before the amalgamation order.

In conclusion, the court approved the scheme of amalgamation with the specified conditions, emphasizing the importance of proper legal procedures and compliance with tax obligations and legal liabilities post-amalgamation.

---