2003 (12) TMI 357 - AT - Customs

Customs House Agent's license suspension shortened on appeal, allowing resumption with new security deposit.

The appeal was allowed, and the suspension of the Customs House Agent's license was restricted until 31st December 2003 instead of the original date of ... Customs House Agent’s Licence - Suspension of - Forfeiture of security Issues:1. Appeal against suspension of CHA license and forfeiture of security deposit.Analysis:The appellant, a Customs House Agent (CHA), appealed against the suspension of their license and the forfeiture of the security deposit by the Commissioner of Customs, Chennai. The Commissioner's order suspended the license until 31-8-2004 and forfeited the security amount of Rs. 25,000. The appellant argued that the continuation of the suspension until 31-8-2004 would cause significant hardship as they had been without business since 26-8-2000. The appellant requested the setting aside of the order of forfeiture, citing it as their first mistake of this nature.The Judicial Member, after considering the submissions from both sides and reviewing the case records, found that the CHA had already been penalized by having their license suspended intermittently for over three years. The Member deemed it harsh to continue the suspension for another year, considering the impact on the appellant's business operations and financial condition. The Commissioner's decision to forfeit the security amount was upheld, as the Member believed that the CHA had been adequately penalized. To address the situation justly, the Member decided to restrict the suspension of the license until 31st December 2003. It was further ordered that from 1-1-2004, the CHA could resume operations as an agent in the Customs House upon furnishing a fresh security deposit of Rs. 25,000. The appeal was allowed based on these terms.