Provisional assessment refund claims need not face separate limitation bars where the discount claim was already asserted before finalisation.

In provisional assessments, a separate refund claim under Section 11B need not be insisted upon merely because duty relief arises from additional quantitative discount, where the assessee had already asserted the claim through declarations and correspondence before finalisation. The ordinary six-month limitation for refund claims was held not to bar such a claim in these circumstances, especially for periods prior to the 1-8-98 amendment to Section 11B. The matter was therefore required to be re-examined by the original authority on the basis of the material already filed, with the rejection set aside and the issue sent back for fresh adjudication on merits.

---

---

Issues: Whether the refund of duty arising from additional quantitative discount was barred for want of a separate refund claim under Section 11B, and whether the matter called for remand in view of provisional assessment and the correspondence placed before the assessing authority.

Analysis: The appeals related to assessments made on RT 12 returns, where the assessee had earlier furnished declarations and letters concerning quantitative discount and requested credit of the duty element. The Tribunal noted that the claims pertained to the period prior to the 1-8-98 amendment to Section 11B and that the assessments were provisional. In that situation, a separate refund claim within six months from the date of payment of duty was not required to be insisted upon. The Tribunal further held that the time-limit applicable to ordinary refunds did not bar the claim when the assessee had been asserting the discount claim before finalisation of assessment.

Conclusion: The refund claim was not time-barred, and the matter was required to be examined afresh by the original authority on the basis of the correspondence and material already filed by the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeals were allowed to the extent of setting aside the rejection and the matters were sent back for fresh adjudication on merits.

Ratio Decidendi: In cases of provisional assessment, a separate refund claim under Section 11B need not be insisted upon merely on the ground of limitation when the assessee has already asserted the claim before finalisation of assessment.

---